Gachagua had filed two petitions contesting his impeachment, but later sought to withdraw them, arguing they had been overtaken by events.

However, on Tuesday, May 20, lawyer Kelly Maleya moved to court to block Gachagua from withdrawing the petitions.
Lawyer Maleya argued that the cases raised weighty constitutional and public interest issues, and should therefore go on to a full hearing.
“The intended Petitioner seeks to take over the said Petitions and prosecute them to conclusion, noting that they raise public interest issues more particularly on the impeachment process of a Deputy President and in this case, the impeachment of the 2nd Deputy President of the Republic of Kenya, Hon Rigathi Gachagua,” Maleya stated in his application.
Maleya further expressed his intention to take over and prosecute the cases originally filed by Gachagua, who now leads the newly launched Democracy for the Citizens Party (DCP).
Gachagua had initially filed the petitions seeking to block both the National Assembly and the Senate from proceeding with a special motion aimed at removing him from office on 11 grounds.
But after months of court battles, his legal team withdrew the cases, citing changed circumstances.
The withdrawal coincided with two major developments: Gachagua’s resignation from the ruling United Democratic Alliance (UDA) and the launch of his new party, DCP, on Thursday, May 15, 2025.
“We respectfully request that when placing the petitions that were subject to the appeal before the Honourable Chief Justice, in compliance with the Court of Appeal’s directive, please bring to her attention the notice of withdrawal for consideration when empanelling a bench,” Gachagua’s withdrawal application read.
Maleya, in his counter-petition filed Tuesday, urged the court to treat the matter as urgent and to prioritize the hearing, citing the constitutional implications of the impeachment.
The legal standoff comes just days after the Court of Appeal overturned Deputy Chief Justice Philomena Mwilu’s decision to constitute a three-judge bench to hear Gachagua’s petitions. The court ruled that only Chief Justice Martha Koome had the authority to empanel such a bench.
Observers see Gachagua’s withdrawal of the pre-impeachment petitions as a strategic shift, possibly to focus on post-impeachment legal battles but with Maleya’s fresh challenge, the courtroom drama is far from over.
